Related Articles
Watch Out for These Common Diamond Scams. Buying a diamond is often a significant and emotional investment, whether it’s for an engagement, a special gift, or a personal milestone. Unfortunately, the diamond industry is rife with tricks and scams that prey on consumers’ limited knowledge. While some of these tactics are minor, others can lead to major financial losses. Here are some of the most common diamond scams you should be aware of—and how to protect yourself.
1. Carat Total Weight (CTW) Deception
One of the most frequent tricks used by jewelry stores involves how they present the diamond’s weight. Often, a jewelry tag will highlight the total carat weight of all diamonds in a piece rather than specifying the carat size of the main (center) stone. This can mislead customers into thinking the center diamond is larger than it actually is.
Pro Tip: Always ask for the exact carat weight of the center stone. Also, be cautious of fractions. For example, a diamond advertised as ¾ carat could legally be just slightly over 0.70 carats.
2. Misleading Fluorescence Marketing
Some jewelers may describe a diamond as having a “blue-white” quality, making it sound exotic or high-end. In truth, diamonds with strong blue fluorescence can sometimes appear hazy or milky, making them less valuable, not more.
Pro Tip: Always view a diamond under different lighting conditions—not just under the store’s bright spotlights. Natural or subdued lighting will give you a more accurate idea of the stone’s clarity and brilliance.
3. The Low-Ball Appraisal Scheme
Another sneaky trick involves dishonest jewelers who offer free appraisals. They may downplay the value of a diamond you own, claiming it’s worth far less than it actually is. Then they might offer to “take it off your hands” or trade it in for another diamond—plus some extra cash on your part.
Pro Tip: Never accept a single appraisal as fact. Always seek multiple professional opinions from independent and certified gemologists before making any decisions.
4. Diamond Switching
This is one of the most alarming scams: after you’ve chosen and paid for a diamond, some unethical jewelers may swap it for a lower quality stone when setting it into a ring or resizing the jewelry. Without expert knowledge or verification, the average consumer might never notice.
Pro Tip: Only deal with reputable and trusted jewelers—ideally those with longstanding reputations and certifications. Avoid leaving your diamond unsupervised with unfamiliar stores.
Final Advice: Shop Smart and Stay Informed
Scams in the diamond industry often rely on the buyer’s lack of knowledge. To avoid being taken advantage of:
-
Educate yourself about the 4Cs of diamonds: Cut, Color, Clarity, and Carat.
-
Request certificates from reputable organizations like GIA or AGS.
-
Always read the fine print and compare products before purchasing.
-
Build a relationship with a jeweler you can trust.
By being cautious and asking the right questions, you can ensure that your diamond purchase is both beautiful and truly worth its price.
